Rich Hill (SP), CHC - Alert: LOW
April 24, 2007
News: Rich Hill's string of shutout innings was stopped at 19.1 innings following Prince Fielder's two-run home run in the fourth inning Tuesday. Hill picked up his first loss of the season as the Cubs lost, 4-1, to the Brewers.
Views: Hill had been brilliant to start the season (3-0, 0.41 ERA, 0.68 WHIP), so he had to settle back toward the norm eventually. Hill allowed four runs on six hits and three walks over 6.2 innings. He did strike out five, but allowed home runs to Fielder and Kevin Mench.
He probably had his highest value before tonight, but he didn't really stink it up badly tonight, so he should still have a lot of excess value. There's very little chance that his ERA remains very far below three, and it certainly won't remain below two. You might get someone to bite big.
I agree, he's definitely worth holding on to, I know I am.
fyi: I asked this question about 5 weeks ago and it was almost unanimous from the members of FIC that James was the better pitcher. At the time, I needed a closer because I only had 1 on my roster, and I had plenty of SPs and the option of either trading Hill or James, so I ended up trading Hill and Im kinda kicking myself for it...
I've seen James pitch a couple of times this season. Despite the fact he's more of a fastballer and doesn't have the big ol' curveball, James still reminds me of Hill before Hill put it together late last season. James has that strikeout ability Hill has, but he's been susceptible to the long ball like Hill is. He's showing the same lack of confidence that Hill showed early last season. I can't predict a Hill-like breakout this season, but if he can bottle whatever Hill did last summer, I wouldn't be surprised to see such a breakout. It's just hard to predict. I'd be patient with James.