Brandon Marshall

Posts: 598 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 3:24 pm

Too much for BMarsh?

I give Chad Johnson and Steve Slaton

I get Brandon Marshall

None of my big name recievers were producing, so I am trying to get one who does. Too much?

Posts: 2000 · FIC Hall-of-Famer Joined: 30 Apr 2004 Posts: 2000

not enough....

Posts: 598 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 3:45 pm

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

Posts: 3955 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 3:54 pm

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

Posts: 598 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 3:58 pm

mjsully10 wrote:

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

well sick, cuz he accepted it!

Posts: 381 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 4:18 pm

marshall will be #1 reciever this year barring injuries.

Posts: 6770 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 4:42 pm

bostonrules88 wrote:

mjsully10 wrote:

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

well sick, cuz he accepted it!

great 4 you, but this guy must be mentally challenged or something because that trade is just ridiculous

Posts: 2000 · FIC Hall-of-Famer Joined: 30 Apr 2004 Posts: 2000

mjsully10 wrote:

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

Agreed Sully...But whats with "if Palmer is done"?
Do you know something I dont?
I just heard it was some shoulder soreness...

what gives? I need to make a move now if its serious...

Posts: 598 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 5:49 pm

Dman33 wrote:

mjsully10 wrote:

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

Agreed Sully...But whats with "if Palmer is done"?
Do you know something I dont?
I just heard it was some shoulder soreness...

what gives? I need to make a move now if its serious...

Palmer's got a sore throwing elbow. Doctor's told him to sit so he could rest and heal. He insists he'll be ready for Dallas this week, but we'll see. Elbow could be serious, maybe not. Do some research and see what's going on.

Posts: 2000 · FIC Hall-of-Famer Joined: 30 Apr 2004 Posts: 2000

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

mjsully10 wrote:

bostonrules88 wrote:

Dman33 wrote:

not enough....

You're saying I'm giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall or I'm not paying enough to get Brandon Marshall?

You are not giving enough. Marshall is a top 3 WR and Ocho Stinko is at best a top 15 WR, but could finish out of the top 20 if Palmer is done. Slaton is a flyer, holding little value based off a one week performance.

Agreed Sully...But whats with "if Palmer is done"?
Do you know something I dont?
I just heard it was some shoulder soreness...

what gives? I need to make a move now if its serious...

Palmer's got a sore throwing elbow. Doctor's told him to sit so he could rest and heal. He insists he'll be ready for Dallas this week, but we'll see. Elbow could be serious, maybe not. Do some research and see what's going on.

Well, im REALLY tired of his crap...I'm about ready to drop Palmer and pickup Edwards,Orton,Kitna,Schaub,Griese..Hell even Flacco would be better ATM....

Posts: 381 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 6:13 pm

Flacco is not really and option but man I think this guys is gona be a good player someday, did anyone else notice how smooth the ball comes out of his hand, he's got a really nice delivery.

Is O Sullivan available? hes a good option too, he's my Brady fill in one of my leagues.

Posts: 2000 · FIC Hall-of-Famer Joined: 30 Apr 2004 Posts: 2000

Iguanas wrote:

Flacco is not really and option but man I think this guys is gona be a good player someday, did anyone else notice how smooth the ball comes out of his hand, he's got a really nice delivery.

Is O Sullivan available? hes a good option too, he's my Brady fill in one of my leagues.

Gone....Would you drop Palmer at this point?

Posts: 2000 · FIC Hall-of-Famer Joined: 30 Apr 2004 Posts: 2000

Collins,Russell,Pennington and Bulger are also options

Posts: 381 · Posted: Sep 30, 2008 6:55 pm

Sorry Cant tell you if you should drop Palmer I have not been following his circus too much lately but I would probably hang on to him.

I would say you have a great match up with either
Schaub vs IND or Edwards vs @AZ

Edwards is probably a safer pick Schaub Big hit potential.