since 2002

Bobby Witt Jr. or Corey Seager

SS Age: 24 Bats: R Throws: R

This Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.28898279236.842

Rank (preseason)

2 ADP
1 SS

Career Stats

Bobby Witt Jr.
ABBAOBPOPS
1867 .288 .336 .842
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 590 82 20 80 30 .254 .295 .724
2023 641 97 30 96 49 .276 .319 .814
2024 636 125 32 109 31 .332 .389 .977

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home912.323.371.938
road955.254.302.749
day746.290.339.836
night1121.287.334.845
vs RHP1455.290.342.851
vs LHP412.282.315.808
none on 1139 .274 .320 .815
risp 212 .354 .423 .998
loaded 24 .208 .207 .832
April 302 .248 .285 .692
May 325 .265 .313 .830
June 307 .283 .336 .792
July 272 .371 .401 1.041
Aug 329 .292 .343 .927
Sept 294 .276 .335 .760
SS Age: 31Bats: L Throws: R

This Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.2807630792.874

Rank (preseason)

39 ADP
7 SS

Career Stats

Corey Seager
ABBAOBPOPS
3964 .290 .360 .872
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 593 90 33 83 3 .245 .317 .772
2023 477 87 33 96 2 .327 .390 1.013
2024 475 68 30 74 1 .278 .353 .865

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home1915.296.366.921
road2049.286.355.826
day1182.294.367.898
night2782.289.358.861
vs RHP2668.299.377.910
vs LHP1296.272.326.794
none on 2341 .276 .339 .838
risp 432 .317 .445 1.003
loaded 75 .347 .356 .916
April 693 .264 .346 .764
May 595 .269 .352 .856
June 500 .314 .388 .942
July 525 .324 .386 .952
Aug 804 .299 .359 .895
Sept 761 .283 .346 .862

So, Who's Better?

DFS Contests

Most of last season, Witt Jr. cost quite a bit more than Seager (in general, at least 10% more). While most of that is due to the slighter better offensive numbers, the speed potential makes up the rest. Every time Witt Jr. is on base, hes a legit threat to steal... especially with the new rules. And we all know how a bag can give your daily score a huge boost.

With Seager, you get a bit more consistency overall. That comes from nearly a decade of MLB experience. So, he's faced the majority of the pitchers in the bigs and has a solid game plan going into most ABs. That usually results in quality ABs and increases his odds of getting on base... and tallying DFS points. Like most lefties, his splits take a significant hit against southpaws, especially the elite ones. So, when Texas faces a tough lefty, be sure to devalue Seager a bit or skip him altogether.

Traditional Roto Leagues

Established vet vs wunderkind, this one's a solid matchup. Seager's battled through injuries and a big trade to become a legitimate top 5 SS. He's found a home in Texas, already won a world series and has consistently produced over the past few years. A solid defensive shortstop with average range, his major weakness is speed. The lack of 20+ SBs puts him at a definite disadvantage compared to the new crop of power and speed shortstops. Even so, his slash line of .280/.360/.950 (BA/OBP/OPS) is still a great asset for most fantasy teams.

Bobby Witt Jr. is one of the fastest rising stars in the bigs. He has he pedigree (dad was a major leaguer), all the physical skills and the mental makeup. Just a few years into his career, he's already established himself as an elite SS. Heck, he's arguably the top shortstop in he game and will be the first one taken in most drafts. A slash line of .320/.380/.975 mixed in with 30 HR,30 SB potential will do that.

Related

Corey Seager
or
Oneil Cruz
Gunnar Henderson
or
Bobby Witt

What's your take?