since 2002

Freddie Freeman or Bryce Harper

1B Age: 35 Bats: L Throws: R

Next Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.314101229114.919

Rank (preseason)

21 ADP
2 1B

Career Stats

Freddie Freeman
ABBAOBPOPS
7558 .300 .387 .899
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 612 116 21 100 13 .325 .407 .918
2023 637 130 29 102 23 .331 .410 .977
2024 542 80 22 89 9 .282 .378 .854

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home3659.296.384.886
road3899.304.390.910
day2116.302.394.919
night5442.299.385.891
vs RHP5195.312.403.942
vs LHP2363.273.352.804
none on 4284 .283 .363 .854
risp 913 .329 .485 .997
loaded 141 .348 .361 .964
April 1131 .292 .385 .888
May 1305 .297 .378 .885
June 1166 .299 .378 .908
July 1170 .312 .397 .932
Aug 1375 .303 .387 .892
Sept 1302 .300 .397 .895
1B Age: 32Bats: L Throws: R

Next Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.28890268712.893

Rank (preseason)

18 ADP
3 1B

Career Stats

Bryce Harper
ABBAOBPOPS
5934 .281 .389 .911
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 370 63 18 65 11 .286 .364 .878
2023 457 84 21 72 11 .293 .401 .900
2024 550 84 30 87 7 .285 .373 .898

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home2965.291.404.952
road2969.272.374.869
day1952.276.392.909
night3982.284.388.912
vs RHP4074.287.399.945
vs LHP1860.268.366.835
none on 3420 .268 .364 .868
risp 625 .280 .465 .966
loaded 111 .324 .369 1.018
April 857 .289 .411 .984
May 959 .272 .377 .912
June 889 .290 .388 .878
July 946 .260 .371 .832
Aug 1129 .303 .396 .955
Sept 1072 .272 .391 .901

Who's Better?

Daily Leagues

Freeman and Harper are obviously both elite and everyday starters. While they both swing the stick from the left side, Freeman tends to hang in a bit better against lefties so if a LHP is out there, we tend to give the slight edge to him. Of course, bullpens get into games much earlier in the modern game so this is less of a factor nowadays.

Season-long Rotisserie

Both Dodger and Phillie lineups are elite so over the course of a full season, they'll both get a ton of RBI chances (and be knocked in a bunch). They're both very patient at the plate so will always flirt with 100 runs a season. The single biggest difference between the two is probably their home parks. Citizens Bank Park is a HR haven, especially during summer. So, Harper has a small ballpark advantage that does play a role over 81 home contests.

Related

Bryce Harper
or
Pete Alonso
Freddie Freeman
or
Matt Olson

What's your take?