since 2002

Gunnar Henderson or Francisco Lindor

SS Age: 23 Bats: L Throws: R

This Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.268106328615.850

Rank (preseason)

8 ADP
3 SS

Career Stats

Gunnar Henderson
ABBAOBPOPS
1306 .268 .346 .850
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 116 11 4 18 1 .259 .348 .788
2023 560 98 28 82 10 .255 .325 .814
2024 630 117 37 92 21 .281 .364 .893

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home661.266.333.838
road645.270.359.861
day481.262.351.833
night825.272.343.859
vs RHP952.283.355.900
vs LHP354.229.324.717
none on 820 .274 .346 .858
risp 119 .227 .356 .835
loaded 26 .308 .344 1.036
April 178 .247 .340 .829
May 175 .217 .341 .821
June 189 .333 .403 1.049
July 196 .260 .333 .787
Aug 225 .262 .314 .781
Sept 312 .285 .346 .859
SS Age: 31Bats: B Throws: R

This Season

2025 Projection
BARHRRBISBOPS
.26696289224.813

Rank (preseason)

13 ADP
5 SS

Career Stats

Francisco Lindor
ABBAOBPOPS
5442 .274 .342 .818
Last 3 Years
YrABRHRRBISBBAOBPOPS
2022 630 96 26 107 16 .270 .339 .788
2023 602 108 31 98 31 .254 .336 .806
2024 618 104 33 91 29 .273 .344 .844

Key Splits

 ABBAOBPOPS
home2636.281.357.841
road2806.267.327.796
day1825.283.350.848
night3617.270.337.802
vs RHP3771.269.338.808
vs LHP1671.287.349.840
none on 3321 .273 .339 .823
risp 621 .258 .356 .767
loaded 110 .336 .380 1.016
April 676 .250 .332 .771
May 883 .273 .342 .811
June 876 .251 .313 .765
July 878 .301 .369 .886
Aug 1053 .300 .354 .829
Sept 992 .273 .346 .862

Who's Better?

DFS Contests

On any given day, Henderson will be about 20% more expensive to draft than Lindor. That's usually a worthwhile trade-off for the potential. Gunnar is a lefty so when there's a tough LHP on the bump, I may steer closer to Lindor (switch-hitter).

Lindor is also incredibly streaky. If he appears to be at the start of a new streak (FanDuel scoring hasn't caught up yet), Lindor can make for a high-value pick. As with most high-tier players, it's mostly about the day's matchup.

Roto Leagues

A classic comparison of vet and rook. Lindor's game is widely known. He's streaky, a free swinger and can put up big numbers... it's just difficult to predict when that will happen. Over the course of a full season, he'll get close to .270/.340/.825 (BA/OBP/OPS). Toss in 20+ bags and you have a top 5 SS.

Henderson has 3 full seasons in his MLB ledger. But, boy, what a first impression. Particularly in 2024, he's taken his game to a new level with a .280/.360/.900 stat line along with 20+ steals. All at the top of the lineup of a young, contending team. MVP-type stuff. Going forward, Gunnar is a first-round pick and in most cases, should be drafted ahead of Francisco.

Related

Gunnar Henderson
or
Bobby Witt
Trea Turner
or
Gunnar Henderson

What's your take?